In this guide
- 01Define the leading need
- 02Find relevant workarounds
- 03Develop concepts together
- 04Test with other users
The lead-user method looks for people who already face an emerging need strongly enough to develop unusual knowledge or their own solutions. It uses that experience to generate concepts, then investigates whether those concepts are useful beyond the original users. Lead users are a deliberately unusual source of insight, rather than a representative customer sample.
Use the method when an important need is changing and ordinary interviews keep describing the limits of current products. It complements customer interviews, trend scouting and open innovation; it does not replace testing with the people a proposed offer will serve.
What makes a user a lead user?
Eric von Hippel’s original lead-user paper focuses on users experiencing needs ahead of a broader market trend. Their experience and attempts to solve those needs can contribute to new concepts. The approach also considers the benefit users expect from obtaining a solution.
An enthusiastic customer, an influential reviewer and an early purchaser are not automatically lead users. The question is whether the person faces the relevant need in an advanced form and has useful experience of addressing it. Status within a community may help you find them, but it is not the criterion.
For example, a person who modifies equipment to operate in a demanding environment may reveal a practical mechanism that an ordinary purchaser has never needed. That does not mean the demanding environment predicts every future customer’s priorities. Establish the trend and the connection to the intended problem rather than assuming that unusual means prophetic.
Find leading needs and existing workarounds
Imagine a hypothetical outdoor-equipment supplier investigating transport of shared gear across rough paths. A volunteer guide has modified a trolley because repeated trips are impractical. The modification includes a different wheel arrangement and a way to secure awkward equipment.

The research question is not whether the guide likes your trolley concept. It is what conditions led to the workaround, what it accomplishes and what remains difficult. Ask for a demonstration where appropriate, with permission and within sensible operating conditions. Record how the existing solution differs from its description.
Before approaching people, define the search field. “People who love the outdoors” is too broad. Specify the task, the trend that might make it more demanding and the capabilities that are currently missing. The opportunity-fields guide helps connect that search to a reasoned innovation direction.
The Lead User Project Handbook describes finding expertise through screening and pyramiding. Screening looks for relevant characteristics in a defined pool. Pyramiding follows referrals toward people with more advanced knowledge, sometimes in an analogous field. These are discovery strategies, not probability sampling methods.
Search beyond the obvious customer list
Ask knowledgeable contacts who encounters the problem more intensely and who has already attempted a solution. A guide may refer you to a trail-maintenance crew, an equipment volunteer or someone moving supplies in a different setting. The analogous user may have a transferable mechanism even though their final product requirements differ.
Keep a referral log. Note who suggested the contact, why the person appears relevant and which aspect of their experience could inform the inquiry. Avoid treating multiple referrals within one close network as independent evidence that the same need is widespread.
Use a short screening conversation:
| Question | What it helps establish |
|---|---|
| What task are you trying to complete? | Relevance to the search field |
| Which conditions make it difficult? | The advanced or demanding need |
| What have you changed or built? | Experience beyond general preference |
| Why was the effort worthwhile? | The benefit of solving the problem |
| What still fails or requires effort? | Unresolved needs and limitations |
| Who faces a similar problem differently? | Further search and analogous expertise |
These are original inquiry prompts. They are not a validated screening scale or a rule that someone must manufacture an object to qualify as a useful contributor. A novel routine or service arrangement may be equally informative.
Turn experience into a concept without taking it over
Bring the advanced users together with people who understand production, servicing and the intended market. Agree how contributions will be acknowledged and how any proposed collaboration will be governed. A workshop invitation does not itself resolve ownership, confidentiality or commercial terms.
Separate the user’s underlying mechanism from the exact homemade solution. The guide’s modification may reduce the effort of negotiating an uneven path, while its weight makes it unsuitable for occasional borrowers. Preserve the insight without assuming that every physical detail should become the product.
Develop several coherent responses. A morphological box can help combine options for carrying, stability, storage and maintenance. A concept brief should then describe who uses the proposed arrangement, under which conditions and what work supports it.
Keep unresolved trade-offs visible. A robust solution may need specialist adjustment. An occasional user may value quick setup more than maximum carrying capacity. Those differences are material evidence for the next inquiry, not objections to remove from the workshop record.
Bring the concepts back to other users
The fictional supplier should next investigate whether ordinary equipment borrowers understand and can use the proposed arrangement. The advanced guide may accept a difficult assembly sequence because the benefit is large; another user may reasonably reject it.

GOV.UK’s user-needs guidance emphasizes understanding the user’s situation before committing to a solution. Apply that discipline again when moving beyond lead users. Ask what other users need to accomplish and what conditions differ, rather than presenting a demanding user’s solution as already validated.
Use concept testing to examine meaning, relevance and concerns. Use task observation to investigate operation. Use an appropriate commercial test if the decision concerns willingness to obtain or pay for the offer. A positive workshop conversation does not answer all three questions.
Also investigate what the supplier would need to support. Maintenance, storage, instructions and replacement components may determine whether a promising mechanism can become a usable offer. The transferable insight can survive even if the initial product configuration changes substantially.
Read the performance evidence carefully
Lilien and colleagues’ study of the lead-user process at 3M reports a natural experiment comparing lead-user projects with more traditional projects. Its prominent sales comparisons concern forecasts, an important limit when interpreting the findings. They are not a universal revenue multiplier or a promise of realized returns for every lead-user programme.
Organizations, project selection and market conditions differ. This guide therefore uses the research to establish that the approach has been studied, while avoiding a general effectiveness claim for the proposed trolley inquiry. The hypothetical narrative includes no real interview, participant quotation or reported result.
When to use another route
If the team needs an estimate of how many current customers encounter a problem, plan a suitable sample and measurement approach. If the problem is poorly understood across ordinary situations, broad exploratory interviews may be the better starting point. If a proposed trend has no credible basis, investigate the trend before searching for its leading edge.
For a first lead-user inquiry, leave with a defined search field, a documented reason each participant is relevant, the workarounds they actually describe and several concepts for further testing. Keep the later market inquiry separate. Advanced experience can expand the solution space without standing in for everyone else’s needs.
Sources:
- Eric von Hippel (1986). Lead Users: A Source of Novel Product Concepts.
- Joan Churchill, Eric von Hippel and Mary Sonnack (2009). Lead User Project Handbook.
- Gary L. Lilien and colleagues (2002). Performance Assessment of the Lead User Idea-Generation Process for New Product Development.
- Government Digital Service (n.d.). Learning about users and their needs.



